Trump’s Lawless Refusal To Allocate Mandatory Federal Funding, For Public Health, As Enacted And Commanded By The Prior Congress — Is In Issue, Here…

We have followed this case since its inception, after Tangerine 2.0 / Musk gutted public health funding — without even a blink at the legal requirements — long well settled, to even attempt such an executive branch power grab.

He/they had no authority to do so — and did so, without any colorable APA-compliance attempt. Thus — we are in DC federal court on this one, almost 19 months on. Here is the full text of this morning’s order, from the able USDC Judge Amir Ali:

…MINUTE ORDER.

The court grants in part and denies in part Plaintiffs’ [230] motion to complete and supplement the administrative record. An administrative record “must include all documents and materials that the agency directly or indirectly considered” to make the challenged decision. Maritel, Inc. v. Collins, 422 F. Supp. 2d 195, 196 (D.D.C. 2006) (quotation marks omitted); see Ctr. for Auto Safety v. Fed. Highway Admin., 956 F.2d 309, 314 (D.C. Cir. 1992) (explaining “review is to be based on the full administrative record that was before the agency at the time it made its decision” (alterations omitted) (quoting Citizens to Preserve Overton Park, Inc. v. Volpe, 401 U.S. 402, 420 (1971))). At the same time, preparing the administrative record is not civil discovery—absent a special circumstance, an agency generally does not have to respond to particular interrogatories or document requests. See, e.g., Air Transp. Ass’n of Am. v. Nat’l Mediation Bd., 663 F.3d 476, 487 (D.C. Cir. 2011); The Cape Hatteras Access Preserv. All. v. U.S. Dep’t of the Interior, 667 F. Supp. 2d 111, 114–15 (D.D.C. 2009).

Applying these standards, the court denies Plaintiffs’ motion insofar as it seeks additional documents related to the decision to allocate funds rescinded by the Rescissions Act of 2025. See ECF No. 230-2 at 1 (item five). Defendants have produced a declaration attesting that they have already produced all documents directly or indirectly considered by agency decisionmakers to allocate those rescinded funds, ECF No. 232-2 ¶ 3, and Plaintiffs have since acknowledged that this satisfies Defendants’ obligations in preparing the administrative record. The court also denies Plaintiffs’ motion insofar as it asks the court to compel supplementation of the record with tabs to a memorandum in the administrative record, which have since been provided and therefore render that part of the motion moot. See ECF No. 230-2 at 1 (item one).

The court grants the motion as to certain areas where the administrative record is incomplete — namely, documents and materials directly or indirectly considered for agency decisions that are within the scope of Plaintiffs’ claims at issue, but that were not accounted for in Defendants’ preparation of the administrative record. [Global Health’s] Plaintiffs’ complaint asserts claims that Defendants did not spend funds in the amounts and for the purposes that Congress appropriated them. See, e.g., ECF No. 174 ¶¶ 127–46. Although the court credits Defendants’ representations that they undertook to provide all documents and materials directly or indirectly relied upon or considered, it is clear from the parties’ briefing and discussions during the court’s hearing that Defendants prepared the administrative record with a narrower conception of Plaintiffs’ claims that focused only on the agency defendants’ subsidiary decision to reserve funds for closeout costs and therefore excluded documents and materials directly or indirectly relied for their decisions about how and on what to spend those funds. See ECF No. 232-1 ¶¶ 5–6; ECF No. 232 at 4.

[The Tangerine 2.0] Defendants shall supplement the record to include all documents and materials that the agency directly or indirectly considered in making their spending decisions for the funds at issue, including obligating documents for the miscellaneous obligations referenced on a memorandum already in the record at A.R. 4009; documents and materials, if any, reflecting calculations or explanations about the amount of funds reserved or obligated for various closeout activities; and documents and materials reflecting the purposes for which global health programs and development assistance funds reserved for closeout activities were used.

To the extent Plaintiffs believe that documents already in the administrative record contain references to such documents and materials that would assist Defendants’ efforts to supplement the record, they shall provide that information to Defendants. See ECF No. 230-2 at 1 (items two, three, and four).

Consistent with Plaintiffs’ proposal in their [231] consent motion to suspend briefing schedule, the parties shall meet, confer, and file a joint status report by November 25, 2026, proposing a feasible schedule for Defendants to complete the administrative record and for renewed summary-judgment briefing as to the claims within the scope of Plaintiffs’ currently pending motion for summary judgment. To the extent the parties also request changes to the separate December 23, 2026, administrative-record deadline and early 2027 briefing schedule for other claims, they may also include a proposal to that effect in their status report.

Signed by Judge Amir H. Ali on 11/20/2026….

What an upside down, Mad Hatter’s Tea Party World this is. Damn — but onward, just the same.

नमस्ते

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.