Again — as with “The Blue-nami of 2026” — sanity is making a comeback, from xenophobic and self-defeating Trump (non-)policy pronouncements. [We were (quietly) keenly following all this — but neglected mentioning it during the peace-filled passing of my mother.]
The very capable USDC Judge Saylor in Boston has held that the Trump Sharpie marks are… arbitrary and capricious — were signed without any investigation into costs and (supposed) benefits — and lacked the required APA procedural safe-guards — so they are. . . at an end, before ever beginning.
Trump/Miller tried to say all student visas end in four years, no matter what. Of course, some of the most brilliant advances across a wide array of the US sciences fields have come from GRADUATE students, here pursuing doctoral credentials — which regularly take a decade or more. About a quarter of all now-$1-billion-plus US startups were founded by foreign born, but US dwelling graduate students.
Thus, Trump’s idiocy threatened the very lead the US built, in foreign-born STEM talent, over the last 50 or so years. Here’s the full USDC opinion — from September — and a bit of it:
…Since 1978, with limited exceptions, the United States has issued visas to foreign students for their “duration of status.” That means, in substance, that nonimmigrants are admitted for the duration of their educational programs. Thus, a student with an F visa may remain in the United States while “pursuing a full course of study at an educational institution. . . or engaging in authorized practical training following completion of studies.”
8 C.F.R. § 214.2(f)(5)(i).That system — which has been in place for nearly half a century — has permitted tens of millions of foreign students and researchers to come to the United States. It has also resulted in groundbreaking research in science, medicine, and technology, substantial economic growth, and a host of other benefits, often on a vast scale. . . .
At any given time, the number of international students, researchers, and professors at American universities is substantial. At present, there are approximately 1.6 million individuals with F visas and 500,000 with J visas. Major research universities typically have large percentages of foreign students, particularly at the graduate level. Thus, for example, for the 2025-26 academic year, more than 40% of the graduate students (and 11.6% of the undergraduate students) at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology were international students.
At Harvard, 38% of the students in the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences are international. At Northeastern, 56.6% of the graduate students are international; at Boston University, the number is 28.4%.
More than half of all international students major in STEM fields (science, technology, engineering, or mathematics). According to a source cited in the complaint, “[i]nternational student alumni have. . . founded one quarter (143 of 582, or 25%) of all the billion-dollar start-ups in the U.S.”. . . .
Already in Tangerine 2.0’s time, foreign enrollment by the most-promising students has fallen off, by about 15% — largely fearing hostile Trumpian / federal lawfare.
This hateful idiocy from Stephen Miller is… suicidal, to our science leads. [Damn — what a pack of howling morons. And yes, this is a spot-on topic, for a blog that narrates US bio-science law and politics.] Onward.
नमस्ते
